Video in Focus: Evaluating New Digital Video Recording Technologies

When evaluating digital platforms, there are many factors that need to be identified. Figuring out real time recording versus time-lapse recording in digital terms along with defining resolution, calculating storage and everything in-between proves to be an ongoing challenge for most. The objective of security management has always been to capture as much quality information as possible using the least amount of recording media. This holds true in digital as well. From the beginning of video in security applications, the standard of measuring real time for all moving images was defined at 30 frames or 60 fields per second.

In today’s world, everything is an acronym. Unfortunately, when selecting and evaluating digital systems there are variations in terminology since different manufacturers use different words. For example, with regard to how much information will be recorded, you will most often find references to ips (images per second) and fps (frames per second, or fields per second). The question you need to ask is if fps stands for “frames per second” or “fields per second?” Or does IPS equate to field or frames? A rate of 30 frames per second is equal to 60 fields or images per second, which is true real-time NTSC video. Some manufactures record at 30 ips while other manufacturers record at 60 ips. Although this seems confusing at first, there are specific differences between the two and should be clarified during the selection process.

What about compression?

The next thing to consider is the compression technology the manufacturer is utilizing. For example, H.263, Wavelet, MPEG-2, MPEG-4, JPEG and MJPEG are a few compression modes you will most often see – each of which offers specific benefits as well as sacrifices. The selection of compression technology for your system needs can vary greatly.

Compression affects both bandwidth and resolution. Some compression methods or hybrid versions are better at passing high quality images at lower bit rates. Some compression technologies are better suited for streaming live video over LANs or WANs. It is somewhat argumentative as to which technology is better suited for recording digital video in security applications. Those questions can be answered through an understanding of one’s intent for their system. Determining the most important factor for your facility will help you decide the most appropriate compression technology for your needs.

Most of the accepted enterprise-level DVR solutions utilize MPEG-2 or MPEG-4 compression and portray resolution as CIF (Common Intermediate Format) or SIF (Source Input Format). A variation of CIF or SIF seems to be the most regularly used. CIF/SIF images are 352 pixels wide and 240 pixels tall.

QCIF is one-quarter CIF and too low a resolution in my opinion to be considered for security applications of any type. CIF is just a tad better resolution than what a VCR produces, and in most cases adequate for back-of-house operations and parking. 4CIF uses 704x480 pixels resolution or 640x480 pixels, roughly four times the area of CIF. This loosely equates to DVD-quality video. This will produce the highest quality images available in today’s marketplace. If budget permits, then by all means go for it. D1 is a newer term being used which produces 720x480 for NTSC and for product evaluation purposes, is comparable to 4CIF. 2CIF varies from product to product but is usually 640x240 pixels, although I have recently seen it defined as 340x480.

If asked where I find the most problems and confusions, the answer would definitely be storage. Storage calculations unfortunately are not the exact science they should be. When calculating storage, stress that it is calculated at 100-percent motion for budget purposes. Manufactures try to stay competitive and storage is the most expensive part of the system. When putting out your request for proposal, be sure to include how many days you will be retaining your video. For example: “system to record 512 cameras at 4CIF RAID5 for no less than seven days.” Buy the system per your parameters. Forget how many Terabytes you are buying. In your contract or proposal, make sure it clearly spells out your desired storage retention so you are covered should it be under-specified.

Although DVRs have come down drastically in price, digital recording is still quite an expensive investment. Be sure to choose a qualified systems integrator who is teamed with a reputable manufacturer. Request demonstrations, then ask to demo the product at your site for a week or two if possible.

Did you enjoy this article? Click here to subscribe to Security Magazine. 

Recent Articles by Cynthia Freschi

You must login or register in order to post a comment.



Image Galleries

ASIS 2013 Product Preview

ASIS International 59th Annual Seminar and Exhibits, September 24-27 in Chicago, Illinois, will include an exhibit hall packed with innovative security solutions. Here are some of the products that will be shown at ASIS this year.


Virtualization and Data Center Security: What You Need to Know for 2014

Data centers are increasingly becoming the center of the enterprise, and data center and cyber security is following the same path for security departments. According to Justin Flynn, a consultant at the Burwood Group, the virtualization of data centers allows enterprises to scale more easily and faster, with a smaller footprint.

However, hosting enterprise data in the cloud can make intrusion detection more difficult – how can enterprise security leaders team up with other departments to keep aware of cyber risks and traffic, and physical and data compliance during the virtual transition? How can CISOs and CSOs discuss cyber threats with the C-Suite to get the resources they need? And how can the proper infrastructure test and verify possible malicious attacks? 

More Podcasts

Security Magazine

Security June 2015 issue cover

2015 June

In this June 2015 issue of SecurityIs the security director business’s new “corporate rock star?” Find out how CSOs can become the new leaders of their enterprises through mentorships, partnerships and creatively adding business value. Also, learn how security professionals are training employees in cyber security through games. And why are deterrence and detection so important when it comes to thwarting metal thieves? Find out in this issue.

Table Of Contents Subscribe

Body Cameras on Security Officers

Body cameras are being used increasingly by police in cities across the U.S. Will you arm your security officers with a body camera?
View Results Poll Archive


Effective Security Management, 5th Edition.jpg
Effective Security Management, 5th Edition

 Effective Security Management, 5e, teaches practicing security professionals how to build their careers by mastering the fundamentals of good management. Charles Sennewald brings a time-tested blend of common sense, wisdom, and humor to this bestselling introduction to workplace dynamics. 

More Products

Clear Seas Research

Clear Seas ResearchWith access to over one million professionals and more than 60 industry-specific publications,Clear Seas Research offers relevant insights from those who know your industry best. Let us customize a market research solution that exceeds your marketing goals.


Facebook 40px 2-12-13 Twitter logo 40px 2-12-13  YouTube  LinkedIn logo 40px 2-12-13Google+

Vertical Sector Focus: Critical Infrastructures

criticalhomepagethumbFrom terrorism to vandalism, it’s preparedness, response, training and partnerships. Learn about some of the critical security issues facing this sector.

Visit the Critical Infrastructure page to read more.